Iraqi Interests are best served by withdrawal of all U.S. troops
by Harry Targ, USA TODAY July 10, 2003
The great folksinger Pete Seeger sang in 1968 of the U.S. sinking deeper and deeper
into "the Big Muddy" that was Vietnam, while "the big fool," President Lyndon Johnson, said, "Push on."
For those of us who remember Vietnam, Iraq seems more and more like "the Big Muddy," as U.S.
troops are targeted for assassination and Iraqis are killed indiscriminately in retaliation.
It is not that the circumstances involving the two U.S. military interventions are the same.
In the Vietnam case, the U.S. engaged in a long and escalating neo-colonial intervention from
1950 until the war was finally lost in 1975.
In Iraq, the intervention that began with the Gulf War in 1991 did not involve growing troop
commitments until the quick and brutal strikes, land and air, against Iraqi targets this
past March.
What is similar, however, is the colossal ideologically driven miscalculation that the growing
guerrilla opposition today is the result primarily of malcontents from the Baath Party who
lost power and wealth with the overthrow of Saddam Hussein, and extremist Iraqis who relish
engaging in acts of terrorism against U.S. and British troops.
As in Vietnam, the explanation for growing violent opposition to U.S. military occupation
is that a tiny and malevolent minority supported by foreign enemies is bent on undermining
the" democratization" of Iraq.
U.S. leaders just never seem to get it. When the U.S. engages in brutal economic strangulation, sends covert operatives to terrorize populations and launches air and land war on targeted populations, the victims of these actions do not regard the aggressors as liberators.
The interests of the Iraqi people and the
increasingly vulnerable young men and women of the
U.S. military occupation would best be served if
the United States negotiates the complete
withdrawal of coalition troops and allows them to
be replaced with a true international peace force
under the aegis of the United Nations.
Nothing less will stop the bloodshed. . Harry Targ
teaches U.S. foreign policy and international
relations at Purdue University. He is the author
of 11 books and 50 articles on these subjects.